| Platinum | Bethlehem Dairy Store |
| Gold | The Cup |
| Silver | Mountain View Drive In |
| Bronze | Dave's Deli & Gelato |
| Top Pick | Crystal Spring Farm |
| Top Pick | Dats Eats, Treats and Sweets |
| Top Pick | Happy Holstein At Klein Farm & Dairy |
| Top Pick | Inside Scoop |
| Top Pick | The Ice Cream Corner |
| Top Pick | Vegan Treats |