| Platinum | Sicily Pizza & Restaurant |
| Gold | Napoli Pizza & Italian Cuisine |
| Silver | Frank' s Pizza & Pasta |
| Bronze | The Brick |
| Top Pick | Arelis Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bruno Scipioni's Italian |
| Top Pick | Fratelli Pizzeria & Cafe |
| Top Pick | NYC Village Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pat's Pizza & Bistro |
| Top Pick | Stefko Pizza |